Ad Age Content Marketing Finalists Are Ads. It’s Wrong and It Matters.

First – a preface. The following submit is a little bit of a rant, and it’s principally directed at me. Mea culpa right here. We at CMI are self-described evangelists of the method and philosophy of content material advertising and marketing. We care. And I fairly frankly have constructed a profession about getting it proper. When others don’t, that accountability lies squarely upon our shoulders.

The irony is apparent. It’s not that they don’t get it. It’s that we haven’t made them care about getting it. In different phrases – it’s our story – however we haven’t instructed it in addition to we might.

Now that mentioned … this one is irksome.

On Monday, Ad Age, the 90-year-old journal protecting advertising and marketing, promoting, and media launched the finalists for its Ad Age A-List and Creativity Awards. They open by saying:

It’s the second the has been ready for: the Ad Age A-List & Creativity Awards finalists. These awards honor the forward-thinking leaders, high companies and artistic innovators within the at the moment. The Agency and Production Company A-Lists are handpicked by the Ad Age editorial employees, who comb by means of lots of of submissions. The Creativity Awards are chosen by esteemed juries led by Ad Age.

Right on the high of the Creativity Awards record are this 12 months’s finalists within the class of … look forward to it … content material advertising and marketing.

They are:

  • HBO – for the built-in advertising and marketing marketing campaign of the ultimate season of Game of Thrones. This was carried out by Droga5 (an advert company that’s now an Accenture firm).

  • Skittles: Advertising Ruins Everything by DDB Chicago and Smuggler (an promoting company and manufacturing firm, respectively).

To be very clear – the work for every of those entries is stellar. Top notch. And we’ll come again to that.

Now, CMI has its personal awards – the Content Marketing Awards. As such, we’re conscious that submissions generally don’t actually comport with the class description. So, in lots of circumstances, you “get what you get” and should award a winner that’s not likely representing the most effective in that class.

With that conundrum in thoughts, I went again to the Ad Age nomination kind for the content material advertising and marketing class. Here’s what it says:

This class acknowledges artistic makes use of of storytelling on any variety of platforms – corresponding to long-form movies, branded content material and native promoting on publishing websites. While at the moment, many would contemplate conventional adverts like spots or print adverts to be ‘content,’ work that can win on this class represents the form of storytelling you wouldn’t anticipate finding inside a standard advert purchase.

This is the place I take situation.

.@AdAge bought #contentmarketing fallacious the second it wrote the awards class, says @Robert_Rose through @cmicontent. Click To Tweet

Create the class – then the class ought to matter

Again, mea culpa right here. For the final 10 years, we at CMI have laid declare to serving to set up a lot of the usual method to a particular method and philosophy. It’s fully doable that we haven’t been clear sufficient.

However, if I used to be a model, a media firm, a consulting agency, or an promoting company and noticed this description, I by no means would have submitted entries for my owned media property, viewers constructing, or unique content material program for consideration within the content material advertising and marketing class to Ad Age.

The first sentence of the class description is the giveaway. Oxford comma however (and I’m an admitted fan), it principally says that content material advertising and marketing is content material distributed by means of a paid mannequin and revealed on anyone else’s web site.

In different phrases, in Ad Age’s class definition, content material advertising and marketing is … once more look forward to it … promoting – solely, , with extra storytelling.

In @AdAge’s class definition, #contentmarketing is promoting with extra storytelling, says @Robert_Rose through @cmicontent. Click To Tweet

Now, if Ad Age wished to characteristic these “sexy” consumer-facing manufacturers that do cool stuff – they may have seemed to any variety of attention-grabbing content material advertising and marketing efforts occurring.

How about:

  • Red Bull’s Rubik’s Cube 2019 Championship. This was an built-in effort from the model final 12 months. Not solely an attention-grabbing bodily occasion, it additionally promoted Red Bull’s owned media platform ThoughtsGamers, which is full of every kind of video games guests can join and play.
  • General Mills’ This is a publication that launched throughout the nominating interval from what I can inform. It is a recipe and cooking web site that comprises unique articles, multimedia, movies, and even a group.
  • Peloton. Now right here’s a model that’s been within the information of late for really remodeling its technique right into a media-based operation. It’s just lately launched apps for Apple Watch, Amazon Fire TV, and different platforms the place you’ll be able to stream unique content material.

Now, are these examples essentially the most deserving efforts in content material advertising and marketing? I don’t know. I actually don’t know if any of them are even profitable. What I do know is that they’re good examples of precise content material advertising and marketing.


It’s solely value main if it issues

We’ve usually mentioned at CMI that, in the end, we don’t actually care if content material advertising and marketing is handled as a separate observe or if it represents a superb, fashionable advertising and marketing method. We simply consider, sincerely, that you must do it effectively.

However, if you happen to are defining it as a definite class to which somebody can submit award-worthy, industry-leading work (and, as you would possibly guess, we’re followers of that), then it actually issues the way you outline it.

After greater than 250 enterprise consumer consulting engagements, workshops, and the final decade of Content Marketing World, I’ve discovered that the most important motive content material advertising and marketing fails in enterprise is as a result of working and measuring the method is misunderstood.

#Contentmarketing fails in enterprise when working and measuring are misunderstood, says @Robert_Rose through @cmicontent. Click To Tweet

Now, candidly, the failure to grasp operations and measurement might be the explanation that the majority advertising and marketing packages fail. Content advertising and marketing isn’t any completely different in that regard from direct advertising and marketing, e mail advertising and marketing, account-based advertising and marketing, and even digital advertising and marketing.

But when a magazine with the attain and affect of Ad Age describes award-worthy content material advertising and marketing as “long-form films, branded content and native advertising” and the “sort of storytelling you wouldn’t expect to find within a traditional ad buy,” effectively, it simply instantly units the observe again a step.

It feels as if Ad Age was simply on the lookout for a catch-all class for a few of the extra artistic advert campaigns, and with content material advertising and marketing being a buzzword, it threw just a few extra finalists from different classes into the combination. It’s as if they only willfully mentioned “owned media isn’t really our thing – so it doesn’t matter what we call it. Let’s just create a category where we can throw some cool creative stuff.”

And – to be clear once more – this inaccurate categorization does the finalists in Ad Age’s awards program a disservice as effectively. The three finalists ARE consultant of wonderful work – simply not content material advertising and marketing:

  • The Game Of Thrones marketing campaign is an epic instance (and actually probably the greatest I’ve ever seen) of name extension.
  • The Sandy Hook advert – whereas disturbing on so many ranges – is a robust instance of persuasive, basic promoting within the doing-good class.
  • The Skittles content material is a extremely humorous, partaking, long-form commercial. So, maaaaaaybe name that branded content material if you’ll. But, I’d posit that’s a skillfully executed commercial.

But as a result of they’re being misclassified as content material advertising and marketing, the individuals who do care about content material advertising and marketing query the management there. And, the individuals who both don’t care about or don’t perceive content material advertising and marketing will surprise why they weren’t finalists in Best Work For Good, Experiential Campaign of the Year, or Craft of the Year.

We often characteristic our Content Marketing Award winners every year – and will accomplish that once more in 2020. In 2019, dozens of wonderful efforts got here from advert companies, publishers, consultancies, and even the manufacturers themselves:

  • SAP launched a tremendous podcast that gained an award.

  • Northwell Health and its company Revmade gained an award for a tremendous owned media web site.

  • Nulon, a household owned Australian motor oil model, gained an award for a branded content material marketing campaign.

I do know the parents at Ad Age are going through a remodeling and altering panorama. We all are. I do know from firsthand expertise they’re proficient, sensible, and terribly passionate in regards to the area of selling, promoting, and artistic media.

But in a world the place the subsequent nice, artistic, award-worthy advertising and marketing is coming from manufacturers launching their very own media platforms and the media corporations, companies, and consultancies serving to them, the age of adverts is altering.

HANDPICKED RELATED CONTENT: Latest Winners of Content Marketing Awards Up the Game

Stay abreast of the newest information, hear from attention-grabbing content material entrepreneurs, and be pointed to useful content material in The Weekly Wrap, a podcast from CMI’s Chief Strategy Officer Robert Rose. Subscribe at the moment:

Register for Content Marketing World to spend 4 days talking with, and studying from, company leaders excelling in content material advertising and marketing for his or her purchasers and for his or her companies.

Cover picture by Joseph Kalinowski/Content Marketing Institute

Source hyperlink Content Marketing

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.